Business & Economy ยท Pan-African
Africa's New Credit Rating Agency Faces Test of Credibility as It Prepares First Sovereign Ratings
The African Union's Africa Credit Rating Agency, launched on 7 October and based in Mauritius, expects to issue its first sovereign ratings by the end of March. Its interim chief says it is in talks with 15 governments, while the established agencies dispute claims of bias against African borrowers.
The African Union has launched the Africa Credit Rating Agency (AfCRA), an initiative African leaders first endorsed in 2017. The agency is based in Port Louis, Mauritius, and is meant to assess African governments and corporate borrowers using local data and expertise, complementing ratings from international agencies. Its first sovereign ratings are expected by the end of March.
Interim chief executive Sifiso Falala says the agency is in discussions with 15 African governments. Research is planned in countries including Mauritius, Kenya, Togo, the Seychelles and Burundi. Beyond sovereigns, AfCRA intends to rate companies, municipalities, banks and local-currency debt.
The case for the agency rests partly on cost. A 2023 UN Development Programme study estimated that subjectivity in sovereign ratings cost African countries $74.5 billion through excess interest payments and foregone lending. Moody's, S&P Global Ratings and Fitch Ratings have disputed that their assessments systematically disadvantage African borrowers. Moody's Marie Diron said at a Chatham House event in June that its analysis of four decades of default data showed similarly rated sovereigns had broadly the same default probability regardless of region.
Falala said many African countries hold speculative-grade ratings despite never having defaulted. He said AfCRA aims for more accurate ratings, not more favourable ones. Nigerian analysts Abdussalam Muazu and Dayo Obisan said local knowledge and better data on informal trade, mobile money and community finance could reduce the uncertainty investors price in.
The agency describes itself as privately owned and self-funded. Its sovereign ratings will be solicited, meaning governments pay for them. The African Union says governments may not own shares in AfCRA. The commentary notes that the agency must still show transparent methodology and safeguards against conflicts of interest, and that additional ratings will not automatically lower borrowing costs.