Opinion & Thought Leadership · East Africa

Badme Again: Why the Ethiopia-Eritrea Drums Demand More Than Regional Silence

By: Amara Tesfaye

Troop build-ups, artillery exchanges and diplomatic silence around Badme have revived fears of a second Ethiopia-Eritrea war. This column argues that the muted response from Addis Ababa, Asmara and the African Union is itself dangerous, and that East Africa's institutions must act now, not after fighting resumes.

Of all the developments competing for attention in East Africa this week, one carries consequences that dwarf the rest: the return of soldiers to Badme. According to the conflict-monitoring group ACLED, Eritrean forces re-entered the disputed border town last week, months after withdrawing in October, and both sides are now trading artillery fire while reinforcing positions at Gual Gemhalo and Sembel. ACLED's own assessment is blunt — the risk of a major confrontation along this front is now high. That single sentence, from an organisation whose business is measuring conflict risk rather than dramatising it, should concentrate minds across the region.

It is worth being precise about what is known and what is not. Reporting attributes claims of trench-digging on the Ethiopian side and of a brief Ethiopian incursion into Eritrean territory to anonymous humanitarian and security sources, not to official confirmation. Neither the Ethiopian nor the Eritrean government, nor the African Union, responded to requests for comment. That triple silence is itself a data point. Two states that severed diplomatic relations in early October, and whose troops are now close enough to exchange fire, have offered the public nothing — no reassurance, no denial, no account of intentions. Analysts quoted in the reporting disagree on what comes next: Kjetil Tronvoll warns that the concentration of forces raises the chance of skirmishes, while Edward Bach of Verisk Maplecroft judges that both governments are more likely to consolidate positions than launch full war, given the heavy costs either would bear. Readers should treat both as informed interpretation, not certainty. Nobody supplying this reporting claims to know whether Badme will see a repeat of 1998-2000, when the same contested town triggered a war that killed tens of thousands.

What can be argued with more confidence is that the architecture meant to prevent exactly this kind of escalation is conspicuously absent from the story. The same week that troops massed at Badme, IGAD's member states gathered in Mogadishu to adopt a 2026-2030 roadmap for CEWARN, the bloc's early-warning mechanism, built around strengthening national units and preventing election-related and climate-linked violence. It is a reasonable, even necessary, piece of institution-building for a region of more than 261 million people. But its unveiling alongside an unaddressed, active military build-up between two IGAD-adjacent states is an uncomfortable juxtaposition. An early-warning system is only as credible as its willingness to sound the alarm on the crisis unfolding in front of it. Separately, a coalition of Horn of Africa diaspora groups protested outside the US State Department demanding international intervention over Ethiopia's conflicts — a sign that communities with direct stakes in the outcome do not believe regional or domestic channels are responding adequately.

There is a temptation, understandable after years of false alarms along this border, to treat the Badme build-up as posturing that will again dissolve into consolidation rather than war. Bach's assessment lends some weight to that view, and it would be irresponsible to predict catastrophe on the basis of artillery exchanges alone. But complacency carries its own risk. Ethiopia is not merely facing an external rival; ACLED notes that Tigrayan forces and an Afar-Amhara rebel alliance formed in late September, explicitly aimed at toppling the federal government, are also present in the Badme area. A border conflict layered onto an internal insurgency is a materially different and more dangerous proposition than a bilateral dispute alone, because it multiplies the actors with an interest in escalation and reduces the chance that either government can de-escalate without appearing to concede ground domestically.

For ordinary citizens across East Africa, the practical stakes are not abstract. A renewed Ethiopia-Eritrea war would displace populations in an already fragile border region, strain humanitarian capacity, and almost certainly complicate the diplomatic and trade relationships Addis Ababa maintains with its neighbours — relationships that countries like Kenya and Uganda, currently courting infrastructure financing and regional cooperation of their own, have every reason to want insulated from instability. It would also test whether the African Union, which did not respond to requests for comment this week, retains any practical capacity to mediate a crisis on the continent's own soil, as opposed to issuing statements after the fact.

The argument here is not that war is inevitable, nor that outside powers should impose solutions on two sovereign states with long, complicated histories of grievance. It is narrower and, I think, defensible: silence from Addis Ababa, Asmara and the AU in the face of documented troop movements and artillery exchanges is not neutral. It forecloses the diplomatic space in which de-escalation becomes possible, and it leaves regional bodies like IGAD exposed to the charge that their early-warning ambitions are aspirational rather than operational. The minimum that citizens of the region should expect is an official acknowledgment of what is happening at Badme, from at least one of the parties capable of ending it — and a clear signal from IGAD or the AU that monitoring has moved to engagement. Until that happens, the gap between institutional rhetoric and events on the ground will keep widening, and East Africans will be left, as before, watching a border they cannot control decide outcomes they cannot avoid.

Reporting context: - Troop Build-Up Near Badme Raises Fears of Full-Scale Ethiopia-Eritrea War: /article/troop-build-up-near-badme-raises-fears-of-full-scale-ethiopia-eritre-336d62760b - Ethiopia-Eritrea Border Tensions Rise Around Badme as Troops Mass on Both Sides: /article/ethiopia-eritrea-border-tensions-rise-around-badme-as-troops-mass-on-5762ee9a1f - IGAD Adopts 2026-2030 Early-Warning Roadmap at Conflict Prevention Meeting in Mogadishu: /article/igad-adopts-2026-2030-early-warning-roadmap-at-conflict-prevention-m-bb0a9eea65 - Ethiopia and Eritrea Reported to Be Massing Forces Along Border, Raising Fears of War: /article/ethiopia-and-eritrea-reported-to-be-massing-forces-along-border-rais-b1548c8c53 - Ethiopian Rebel Groups Call for UN-Brokered End to Conflict: /article/ethiopian-rebel-groups-call-for-un-brokered-end-to-conflict-9b7fa37daf - Horn of Africa Diaspora Protests Outside US State Department Over Ethiopia Conflicts: /article/horn-of-africa-diaspora-protests-outside-us-state-department-over-et-d801b25dee

More reporting from Voice of Africans