Pan-African ยท Pan-African
Experts Divided on Who Gains Most From Russia-Africa Partnership After Moscow Summit
Three analysts offered contrasting views on whether Russia's ties with Africa deliver real economic gains, after a Moscow summit attended by 48 African countries. They discussed trade falling short of a $40 billion pledge, investment prospects, and Russian security roles in the Sahel.
Russia's partnership with Africa is under renewed scrutiny over trade, investment and security cooperation, after a Moscow summit that brought together representatives from 48 African countries. In a panel debate, three experts gave differing views on whether closer diplomatic ties are producing tangible benefits for African economies and citizens.
Russia pledged in 2019 to lift annual trade with Africa to $40 billion. Participants put the current figure at around $29 billion, well below that goal.
Andrey Maslov, director of the Centre for African Studies at HSE University in Moscow, said trade figures alone do not capture the relationship's potential and that investment should be the next step. He pointed to logistics, food security, healthcare and education, including infrastructure, fertiliser production and scholarships. He also cited competition from China and growing African domestic production as factors shaping trade prospects.
Dr Mikatekiso Kubayi of the University of Johannesburg said African governments should use global interest in the continent to negotiate investment, technology transfer, joint research and local industrial development. He said Russia should not be expected to replace partners such as the United States.
On security in Mali, Burkina Faso and Niger, Beverly Ochieng of Control Risks said Moscow had built on existing anti-Western sentiment, and questioned whether its political visibility matched its economic weight. She warned that foreign forces' involvement in active operations could hinder national armies' self-reliance and said some agreements are hard to scrutinise. Maslov said Russian personnel work alongside national forces under agreements with governments, and that "the decision making is theirs".
Ochieng expected Russia to remain strategically important but economically limited compared with China and the European Union. Maslov rejected judging the partnership by who benefits more.