International ยท Pan-African

Experts Question Whether Russia Can Anchor a Multipolar Order With Africa After Moscow Summit

After the third Russia-Africa summit in Moscow, which drew delegations from 48 countries, analysts disagree on whether Russia can deliver on its multipolar rhetoric. Critics point to limited trade and sanctions pressure, while a Moscow-based expert stresses shared history and cooperation in agriculture and food supply.

The third Russia-Africa summit has ended in Moscow with delegations and leaders from 48 countries taking part. The Kremlin used the gathering to promote a vision of Russia and Africa as allies in building a multipolar world order free of dictates, and it has voiced support for two permanent African seats on the UN Security Council.

Analysts quoted in the discussion say that ambition faces practical limits. Mohamed al-Sharqawi, a professor of international conflict resolution, argues that Moscow has sought since 2019 to win strategic influence in Africa, taking advantage of declining French influence and what he describes as faltering US influence. He says this is now constrained by an economic contraction in Russia linked to the war in Ukraine and Western sanctions. He adds that Russian trade with the continent rests largely on arms deals, particularly with Egypt and Algeria, while Africa needs development programmes and goods Moscow cannot currently supply.

Naeem Jena, director of a centre for Afro-Middle Eastern studies, describes Russia as a small player from the African perspective. He says trade with the continent totals no more than $27 billion, of which $10 billion goes to Egypt and the rest to 53 other countries, compared with $94 billion for India. He also warns that a growing Russian military presence in the Sahel, Libya and Niger raises concerns that Africa could become an arena for foreign rivalries. African states, he says, treat Russia as one partner among several, including China, Turkey and the West.

Alexander Kuznetsov, a deputy director at a Moscow institute, defends the partnership. He says Russia sees Africans as equal partners, citing Soviet support for decolonisation, and that cooperation extends to agricultural and food technology and wheat exports. He gives the Democratic Republic of the Congo as an example of a country with large farming potential that imports food.

Al-Sharqawi cautions against what he calls a new dependency under another name and calls for an independent African bloc able to negotiate on equal terms with Washington, Beijing, Moscow and Brussels.

More reporting from Voice of Africans