General News ยท South Africa

Johannesburg Court Case Against Ndodana Tshuma Stalls Over Mental Health Evaluation Question

By: Ola Badawy

Proceedings against Ndodana Mkhanyisi Tshuma, wanted by British police over the killings of his wife and two daughters, have been held up in Johannesburg. His lawyer says he cannot recall pleading guilty to firearm and immigration offences, and a mental health evaluation may follow. The case is adjourned to 29 October 2026.

Court proceedings in South Africa involving Ndodana Mkhanyisi Tshuma, who is wanted by British police over the killings of his wife and two daughters, have been delayed amid questions about his mental state, according to his defence team.

Tshuma had previously pleaded guilty to unlawful possession of a firearm and of ammunition. He also admitted an immigration offence for entering South Africa while a fugitive.

At an appearance before the Johannesburg magistrate court on Wednesday, however, he told his lawyers he did not remember entering those pleas or signing a plea agreement. Defence attorney Chrispin Machingura said the defence could not move forward in those circumstances. He said that where mental instability or incapacity is suspected, an application can be made for the accused to be evaluated.

Machingura said he would visit Tshuma again after a week. If Tshuma maintains that he does not recall the pleas, the lawyer said, he will be referred for a mental health evaluation. If he acknowledges them, the case would return to court and proceed.

The state prosecutor told the court that the prosecution was ready to proceed. The magistrate adjourned the matter until 29 October 2026.

The defence says the question over Tshuma's mental health has delayed two scheduled court appearances. The source material does not set out the status of any extradition request or the details of the allegations in Britain.

More reporting from Voice of Africans