Opinion & Thought Leadership · East Africa

Somalia's Court Has Spoken. Will Power Listen?

By: Amara Tesfaye

Somalia's Supreme Court has ruled President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud's extended tenure illegal and ordered elections within 90 days. The judgment, alongside the collapse of Moyale into a regional refugee crisis, tests whether East African institutions can restrain executives who bend constitutions to their advantage.

Somalia's Supreme Court has delivered one of the most consequential rulings in the country's recent political history. On 5 November, five judges unanimously found that President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud's continued hold on office is illegal, rejecting the argument that a March constitutional amendment extending presidential terms from four to five years could retroactively cover his current mandate. The court went further still, nullifying the president's attempt to dismiss the chief justice, a move he had announced on Facebook and justified by invoking the need for "efficient and fair justice." The judges ordered elections within 90 days. This is, by any measure, a judicial rebuke of rare clarity directed at a sitting head of state.

The ruling matters well beyond Mogadishu's corridors of power because it crystallises a dilemma that recurs across the region: what happens when an elected leader uses the machinery of constitutional reform not to strengthen institutions but to extend his own tenure. The president's broader project, a shift from Somalia's indirect clan-based electoral system toward universal suffrage, is not without merit; one-person-one-vote is a legitimate democratic aspiration that many Somalis have long demanded. But the federal states of Puntland and Jubaland, joined by opposition figures, argued persuasively that the timing and sequencing of the reform served a narrower purpose: keeping the incumbent in place. The court's decision, reached despite what observers describe as sustained pressure, suggests the judiciary read the reform the same way. Analyst Abdirashid Hashi's characterisation of the ruling as a setback after "three years of largely unchecked unilateralism" is an interpretation worth taking seriously, though it is one view among several, and the president's own legal and political response remains to be seen.

What should concern readers across East Africa is not simply the outcome in Somalia but the precedent it tests. A court that can tell a sitting president his mandate has expired, and can void his attempt to remove the chief justice who might rule against him, is exercising exactly the kind of independent check that constitutional democracies require. Whether that ruling translates into an actual transfer of power, or whether it becomes another unenforced judgment in a country where federal authority is often contested on the ground, is the question that will define the next 90 days. Somalia's history offers no guarantee that court orders automatically produce political outcomes; the gap between a legal ruling and its implementation has swallowed many African institutional victories before.

This test of institutional resilience is unfolding against a regional backdrop that underscores how quickly political dysfunction becomes human catastrophe. In southern Ethiopia, fighting between Somali and Oromo forces over the town of Moyale, under way since 18 October, has pushed an estimated 50,000 people across the border into Kenya, straining a county where two-thirds of residents already live below the poverty line. UNHCR reports at least 11,000 displaced people sheltering in schools, while stray artillery fire has reportedly killed three people and wounded twenty on the Kenyan side. An analyst cited in the reporting attributes part of the crisis to federal neglect of southern conflicts while attention remained fixed on Tigray, a pattern of displaced governmental priorities that, if accurate, should worry anyone concerned with Ethiopia's federal cohesion. A separate $8.9 million UN appeal for Ethiopians fleeing into Kenya, though sparse on detail, signals that the humanitarian bill for this neglect is now being presented to international donors.

The throughline connecting Mogadishu's courtroom and Moyale's burned homes is institutional fragility: constitutions stretched to serve incumbents, regional borders drawn by past settlements that remain contested, and federal structures too weak or too distracted to prevent local disputes from metastasising into mass displacement. Tanzania's impending verdict in the treason case against opposition leader Tundu Lissu, which carries a potential death sentence and is already seen by civil society as an attempt to silence dissent, belongs to the same pattern of executive power testing the limits of judicial and constitutional restraint.

For African readers, the practical implications are sobering but not without hope. Somalia's judiciary has shown that courts can still act as a check on executive overreach, even under pressure, and that fact alone deserves recognition rather than cynicism. But a ruling is only as strong as the political will and regional support behind its enforcement. East African governments, the African Union, and international partners now face a narrow window to insist that the 90-day deadline is honoured, not quietly shelved. Equally, the Moyale displacement crisis demands that Ethiopia's federal government treat peripheral conflicts with the same urgency it has shown the north, lest neglected borders keep exporting instability to neighbours already stretched thin. The coming months will show whether East Africa's institutions are gaining strength or whether courts and constitutions remain, for now, aspirations rather than guarantees.

Reporting context: - Moyale Fighting Pushes Around 50,000 People From Ethiopia Into Kenya With No End in Sight: /article/moyale-fighting-pushes-around-50-000-people-from-ethiopia-into-kenya-47827b06ce - UN Agencies Appeal for $8.9 Million to Help Ethiopians Fleeing Into Kenya: /article/un-agencies-appeal-for-8-9-million-to-help-ethiopians-fleeing-into-k-253504bec5 - Tanzania's High Court to Deliver Verdict in Opposition Leader Tundu Lissu's Treason Case: /article/tanzania-s-high-court-to-deliver-verdict-in-opposition-leader-tundu--99568ccfdc - Somalia's Supreme Court Rules President's Continued Hold on Power Illegal: /article/somalia-s-supreme-court-rules-president-s-continued-hold-on-power-il-cef288b585 - Somalia's Supreme Court Rules President's Extended Stay in Office Illegal and Orders Elections Within 90 Days: /article/somalia-s-supreme-court-rules-president-s-extended-stay-in-office-il-49ef517b82 - Displaced Ethiopian Families Struggle to Find Food as Aid Groups Scale Back in Camps: /article/displaced-ethiopian-families-struggle-to-find-food-as-aid-groups-sca-4c415309d3

More reporting from Voice of Africans