Opinion & Thought Leadership · Southern Africa

Soul-Searching Is Not Enough: The ANC's Real Test Lies in the Councils

By: Tumi Dlamini

After the ANC's worst-ever local election result, the party promises "soul-searching" while insisting President Ramaphosa stays. Tumi Dlamini argues that continuity is only credible if negotiated local coalitions, now unavoidable, actually fix the service delivery failures driving voters away.

South Africa's local government elections have delivered a verdict that no amount of party messaging can soften: the African National Congress has recorded its worst showing at the ballot box, its vote share falling some 15 percentage points to roughly 31 percent. The party's own secretary-general has called the result "catastrophic," and the leadership has convened a special National Executive Committee session to confront what it describes as a period of "soul-searching." At the same time, the party insists President Cyril Ramaphosa is going nowhere, dismissing talk of his resignation as fabrication. These two postures, contrition and continuity, sit uneasily together, and the tension between them says more about the ANC's predicament than either statement alone.

It is worth being precise about what is known and what is not. The reporting confirms the scale of the defeat, the party's acknowledgment of it, and the spokesperson's insistence that Ramaphosa will stay. It does not yet detail the substance of any internal reckoning, the specific terms on which other parties might support ANC-led councils, or what the mandating guide prepared for the negotiating team actually contains. Separately, a bloc formed by MK, the Economic Freedom Fighters and the South African Communist Party has offered the ANC conditional support in municipalities, though the conditions themselves, the councils involved and the timing of the arrangement remain unspecified in what has been reported. Any assessment of where South African local politics is headed must therefore be read as provisional, built on a partial record rather than a complete one.

Even with that caveat, the trajectory is unmistakable and worth stating plainly: a party that once commanded close to seventy percent of the national vote has now fallen well below a third in local elections, continuing a decline that saw it lose its parliamentary majority two years ago. The ANC has periodically attributed its difficulties to the long shadow of apartheid and colonial dispossession. There is historical truth in that framing, but it is an increasingly thin shield against the proximate grievances voters are reported to cite: electricity shortages, failing water and sewage infrastructure, uncollected refuse, and a housing crisis that leaves millions in informal shacks. These are not abstractions of history; they are the daily texture of municipal failure, and they are precisely the domain in which local government, not national politics, is meant to deliver.

This is why the emergence of a conditional-support bloc among MK, the EFF and the SACP matters more than its sparse reporting might suggest. With no party holding outright majorities in a number of councils, the ANC's ability to govern locally will increasingly depend on negotiated arrangements with rivals and former allies alike, including formations built substantially around criticism of ANC governance itself. That the party now requires a "mandating guide" for its negotiating team to engage other parties is itself a quiet admission that coalition politics, long a feature of some metros, has become the default condition of South African local government rather than the exception.

The counterargument offered by the party, that Ramaphosa is "not under pressure to resign" and should remain to steer reform, deserves fair consideration rather than dismissal. Continuity has genuine value during a period when the party says it is reflecting on its failures; abrupt leadership change could as easily produce paralysis as renewal, and nothing in the available reporting indicates an alternative figure commanding broader support. But continuity is only a credible strategy if the promised soul-searching translates into verifiable changes in how municipalities are run, not merely into reassurances about who sits atop the party. The public record so far gives no indication of what concrete reforms, if any, have emerged from the special NEC session.

For readers across Southern Africa, the practical stakes extend beyond party fortunes. Electricity costs are separately reported to be threatening manufacturing jobs and investment in Nelson Mandela Bay, a reminder that municipal governance failures and economic competitiveness are tightly linked. Coalition instability at local level, if it produces paralysis rather than cooperation, risks compounding exactly the service delivery failures that drove voters away from the ANC in the first place. The test ahead is not whether Ramaphosa remains president, but whether negotiated local governance, however fractious, can produce functioning water systems, reliable power and collected refuse. On that measure, and not on internal party rhetoric, the ANC's "soul-searching" will ultimately be judged.

Reporting context: - MK, EFF and SACP Form Bloc to Push Municipal Agendas, Offering ANC Conditional Support: /article/mk-eff-and-sacp-form-bloc-to-push-municipal-agendas-offering-anc-con-66b51fc2bf - Rising Power Costs Threaten Manufacturing Jobs and Investment in Nelson Mandela Bay</panel>: /article/rising-power-costs-threaten-manufacturing-jobs-and-investment-in-nel-eb545956c6 - ANC Pledges "Soul-Searching" After Election Losses and Says Ramaphosa Will Not Resign: /article/anc-pledges-soul-searching-after-election-losses-and-says-ramaphosa--6310bf9b7f - ANC Says Ramaphosa Is Not Under Pressure to Resign: /article/anc-says-ramaphosa-is-not-under-pressure-to-resign-4ece4c614e - South Africa's ANC Opens Talks Following Election Rout: /article/south-africa-s-anc-opens-talks-following-election-rout-4be9b1eb59

More reporting from Voice of Africans