Opinion & Thought Leadership · Southern Africa

South Africa's Ballot of Broken Taps: Why the ANC's Local Election Reckoning Is Also a Governance Reckoning for the Region

By: Tumi Dlamini

As South Africans vote in local elections widely framed as a referendum on the ANC, the deeper story is governance failure: dry taps, coalition churn and eroding trust. The real test is not which party wins, but whether any coalition can fix the plumbing of the state.

South Africans have cast their ballots in local government elections that commentators and pollsters alike describe as the sternest test yet of the African National Congress's three-decade dominance. That framing is accurate but incomplete. The more consequential story emerging from the reporting is not simply whether the ANC's national vote share slips below the 40 percent, or even the 30 percent, that some polls suggested it might, but whether South Africa's system of municipal governance — regardless of which party or coalition nominally runs it — can actually deliver water, electricity and refuse collection to citizens who have, by every account, run out of patience.

The timing could hardly be more pointed. Just days before polls opened, Johannesburg's mayor, Dada Morero, was still acknowledging that taps in parts of the city had run dry for more than ten days, blaming high consumption and an ageing network he said would cost billions of rands to repair. The South African Human Rights Commission's own inquiry, released on the eve of voting, found that nearly 45 percent of water flowing through Johannesburg's pipelines is lost to poor infrastructure — a figure the Commission separately characterised as evidence of a widespread human rights violation across Gauteng. Pretoria residents were told weeks earlier to stop drinking tap water after roughly 800 people fell ill. Durban has faced long-running shortages of its own. These are not isolated municipal hiccups; they are symptoms of a governance architecture that has, by the Mapungubwe Institute's count, left dozens of the country's 257 municipalities under coalition or minority administrations as of earlier this year — arrangements that analysts link directly to the instability behind poor service delivery.

It is reasonable to interpret the election results, whatever they ultimately show, primarily through this lens of institutional capacity rather than partisan fortune alone. Johannesburg's ten mayors in ten years, Tshwane's four changes of mayoral party since 2020, and Ekurhuleni's three mayors since 2021 suggest that the problem voters are punishing is not reducible to the ANC's brand decline. It is a structural failure of coalition governance to produce continuity of administration long enough for infrastructure maintenance — unglamorous, capital-intensive, apolitical work — to actually happen. A party or alliance that wins more council seats without addressing this churn risks inheriting the same crises under a different letterhead.

There are, of course, legitimate counter-readings. The ANC's defenders, and indeed the party's own leadership, can point to the national government of unity formed after 2024 as evidence that coalition politics in South Africa need not be synonymous with dysfunction; national-level power-sharing between the ANC and the Democratic Alliance has, so far, held. Opposition parties will argue, with some justification, that fresh leadership and genuine accountability mechanisms — rather than more of the same administrations — are precisely what is needed to break the cycle of neglected maintenance. And it would be unfair to lay every infrastructure failure at the feet of any single administration: ageing apartheid-era and post-apartheid networks, population growth, and climate pressures — Gauteng's premier has linked falling reservoir levels to an El Niño-driven heatwave — all compound problems that predate any particular council.

What the reporting does make clear is that whichever parties end up governing Johannesburg, Tshwane, eThekwini and Cape Town after coalition talks conclude, they inherit the same unforgiving arithmetic: water systems losing nearly half their throughput, municipal finance departments described as under-resourced and short of qualified engineers, and an electorate whose primary grievances — water, safety, basic services — were named directly in interviews with ordinary voters from Soweto to Mayfair West. Fragmented results, which polling and analysts both anticipate, make it likely that coalition bargaining itself, rather than any single mandate, will determine who controls these critical cities. That raises a genuine risk: parties preoccupied with assembling majorities may again defer the harder, slower work of fixing pipes and power grids.

For readers across Southern Africa watching from Harare, Maputo or Windhoek, South Africa's municipal crisis carries a broader lesson that transcends any one party's fortunes. Decentralised government only works when local authorities have the technical capacity, financial discipline and political stability to execute long-term infrastructure plans — conditions that frequent leadership turnover actively undermines. The practical implication for South African voters and the parties now negotiating city councils is straightforward, if unglamorous: durability of administration, backed by competent technical staff and transparent financial management, matters as much as which coalition banner governs. The Human Rights Commission's framing of Gauteng's water losses as a rights violation, rather than a mere engineering failure, suggests that courts and oversight bodies may increasingly hold municipalities accountable in ways that elections alone cannot. Whoever assumes office in the coming weeks will be judged, fairly, not on rhetoric about renewal but on whether the taps finally run clean.

Reporting context: - Polls Close in South Africa's Local Elections as Counting Begins: /article/polls-close-in-south-africa-s-local-elections-as-counting-begins-bb5286b2d8 - South Africans Vote in Local Elections Seen as Verdict on Weakened ANC: /article/south-africans-vote-in-local-elections-seen-as-verdict-on-weakened-a-381ce8c309 - ANC Braces for Bruising Local Election Result as South Africans Vote Amid Service Failures: /article/anc-braces-for-bruising-local-election-result-as-south-africans-vote-8c4ec93002 - South Africa Heads to Municipal Polls Amid Service Failures and Fading ANC Support: /article/south-africa-heads-to-municipal-polls-amid-service-failures-and-fadi-b8a647a7ae - South Africa's Human Rights Commission Condemns Gauteng Water Crisis as Widespread Rights Violation: /article/south-africa-s-human-rights-commission-condemns-gauteng-water-crisis-0704c9c802 - Johannesburg Races to Restore Water Supply Days Before South Africa's Local Elections: /article/johannesburg-races-to-restore-water-supply-days-before-south-africa--afc0f42a34

More reporting from Voice of Africans