Opinion & Thought Leadership · Southern Africa
South Africa's Coalition Era Has Arrived — and So Has the Hard Work of Governing
By: Tumi Dlamini
The ANC's worst-ever municipal result, below 31%, ends single-party dominance in South African local government. The real test now is whether fractured councils can deliver water, power and jobs, or whether coalition politics becomes another excuse for paralysis.
South Africa's municipal elections have produced a result that is less a single earthquake than the final collapse of a structure that had been cracking for years. With well over 95% of votes counted, the African National Congress has settled at just over 30%, its weakest showing since the dawn of non-racial democracy in 1994. It has lost its majority in six of the country's eight metropolitan municipalities, including Johannesburg and Pretoria, and it is contested rather than dominant even in cities it once took for granted. The Democratic Alliance, consolidating its position around a quarter of the vote, holds Cape Town outright and is well placed elsewhere. Jacob Zuma's uMkhonto weSizwe party, contesting local elections for the first time, has emerged as a serious third force concentrated in KwaZulu-Natal, while Herman Mashaba's ActionSA has chipped away at ANC strongholds in Gauteng townships. The headline arithmetic is clear enough. What it means for the quality of South African governance is the more consequential, and more uncertain, question.
It would be a mistake to read this primarily as an ideological realignment. The reporting consistently points to a narrower and more practical set of grievances: water and electricity shortages, unemployment above a third of the workforce, crime, corruption and, repeatedly, the simple failure of municipalities to deliver basic services. ANC Secretary-General Fikile Mbalula's own concession that the party "cannot ask the people to trust us merely because of our history" is a notable admission that the liberation-era bond between party and electorate has frayed to the point of near-irrelevance in the places where potholes go unfilled and taps run dry. Analysts cited in the coverage describe the decline as a verdict on mismanagement rather than a rejection of any particular programme. That distinction matters for how opposition parties and prospective coalition partners should interpret their mandate. Voters have not necessarily endorsed the DA's market-oriented governance model or MK's populist appeal so much as they have punished incumbency failure wherever it occurred.
This is where the harder argument must be made. South Africa is entering an era in which no single party can assume automatic control of its major cities, and the coverage is right to flag that coalition government at the local level has historically proven unstable, prone to internal disputes that crowd out service delivery. Johannesburg alone has cycled through multiple mayors in recent years under fractured councils, and there is little in the current numbers to suggest that dynamic will simply disappear. The DA's prospects of governing Johannesburg or Pretoria will depend on partnerships with parties such as ActionSA, whose animosity toward the DA is described by one analyst as extreme even where their policy instincts might align. MK's position in Durban, where it appears to have won the most votes without an outright majority, raises similar questions: a party built substantially around loyalty to a single former president now faces the unglamorous task of forming working administrations and keeping the lights on.
The temptation for all parties will be to treat coalition negotiations as a contest for patronage rather than a mechanism for better governance. That temptation should be resisted, and voters would do well to judge their councillors on precisely this point over the next five years. The opposition parties that have gained ground have done so by promising competence, not by offering a coherent alternative vision for the country's deeper structural problems of unemployment and inequality. A DA-led Cape Town, a contested Johannesburg, and an MK-influenced Durban will each be watched closely as test cases for whether multiparty local government in South Africa can actually fix pipes and collect rubbish, or whether it simply redistributes the dysfunction that voters have just punished.
There are reasonable counterarguments to any claim that this election marks a decisive turning point. Turnout, while higher than in 2021 at 54.5%, still left nearly half of registered voters outside the process, and analysts note that many younger citizens who registered did not cast ballots at all, suggesting disengagement that could temper any reading of this result as a resounding democratic mandate. The ANC, moreover, remains the single largest party nationally even in defeat, and it retains the experience of running government machinery that newer entrants lack. It would be premature to extrapolate a national collapse from local results, though analyst Daniel Silke's suggestion that the outcome offers a signal for the 2029 general election deserves serious attention rather than dismissal.
For readers across Southern Africa, the practical implication extends beyond South Africa's borders. Investors and regional partners who have treated ANC dominance as a proxy for political stability will need to recalibrate, and the coalition-building skills now required of South African politicians may become a template, for better or worse, as other countries in the region confront their own eroding one-party loyalties. The test ahead is not whether parties can win votes by criticising incumbents, but whether they can translate fragmented mandates into functioning city governments. On that score, the jury remains very much out.
Reporting context: - ANC Heads for Record-Low Local Vote and Loses Majority in Six of Eight Metros: /article/anc-heads-for-record-low-local-vote-and-loses-majority-in-six-of-eig-692cb99609 - ANC Posts Worst Result in Its History in South Africa's Local Elections, Analysts Say: /article/anc-posts-worst-result-in-its-history-in-south-africa-s-local-electi-d074db6579 - ANC Set to Miss Outright Majority in All Eight Major Metros as Coalition Talks Loom in South Africa: /article/anc-set-to-miss-outright-majority-in-all-eight-major-metros-as-coali-2f8fa7cbd7 - ANC Heads for Its Worst Ever Result in South Africa's Local Elections With Over 95% of Votes Counted: /article/anc-heads-for-its-worst-ever-result-in-south-africa-s-local-election-6a69320ff6 - ActionSA Wins Township Wards From ANC in Gauteng: /article/actionsa-wins-township-wards-from-anc-in-gauteng-9a88bce743 - MK Party Takes Four KwaZulu-Natal Municipalities From ANC: /article/mk-party-takes-four-kwazulu-natal-municipalities-from-anc-d80fcbb80d