Opinion & Thought Leadership · Southern Africa

South Africa's Coalition Reckoning: The ANC's Decline Demands More Than Arithmetic

By: Tumi Dlamini

The ANC's record-low municipal vote share marks a historic rupture in South African politics. This column argues the real test is not which parties form governments but whether coalitions can be built on competence rather than convenience, and what that means for service delivery and regional confidence in democratic renewal.

South Africa's local elections have produced the most consequential political arithmetic the country has seen since 1994. Final results place the African National Congress at roughly 30.76 percent nationally, its weakest showing in three decades of democratic rule, with the Democratic Alliance trailing at 24.67 percent and Jacob Zuma's uMkhonto weSizwe party emerging as a formidable third force concentrated in KwaZulu-Natal. More than half of the country's 213 municipal councils, and all eight metropolitan municipalities, lack a party with an outright majority. This is not merely a bad night for the governing party; it is a structural shift that will reshape how South Africa's cities are run for years to come.

The facts, as reported, are stark and largely undisputed. President Cyril Ramaphosa has called for the voters' verdict to be respected, while his own secretary-general, Fikile Mbalula, has described the outcome as "catastrophic," acknowledging publicly that communities were left without water, that rubbish went uncollected, and that roads crumbled under ANC stewardship. That a party's most senior organiser would concede such failures so bluntly is itself notable, and it suggests an institution aware that platitudes about liberation history no longer satisfy an electorate grappling with unemployment above 34 percent and persistent service breakdowns.

What should concern readers across Southern Africa is not simply which party wins which city, but whether the coalition governments now being negotiated can function at all. The reporting is consistent on this point: past coalition arrangements in South African local government have frequently been undermined by internal disputes, shifting allegiances and administrative paralysis, often at the direct expense of residents who need water, electricity and refuse collection rather than political theatre. With councils legally required to convene within fourteen days of final declarations to elect mayors, the pressure for swift, durable deals is immense, and the incentives for short-term horse-trading are equally strong.

The emerging contours of these negotiations deserve scrutiny rather than assumption. The DA has signalled it will engage only with parties committed to clean governance, anti-corruption measures and service delivery, a framing that positions it as the arbiter of acceptable coalition partners. Yet reported tensions between the DA and ActionSA, which analysts suggest could hold the balance of power in Gauteng's metros including Tshwane, complicate any notion that ideological alignment alone will determine outcomes. Herman Mashaba's own assessment that coalitions with the DA are "very, very slim" underscores how personal and organisational rivalries, not merely policy differences, will shape governance in cities housing millions of South Africans. Meanwhile MK's control of eThekwini, achieved without a majority, raises its own questions about whether a party built substantially on one leader's political resurrection can deliver the administrative competence that voters across the country have just demonstrated they demand.

There is a reasonable counterargument that this fragmentation, however messy, represents democratic health rather than crisis. Turnout rose to 54.5 percent from 46 percent in 2021, suggesting renewed civic engagement rather than apathy, even if youth participation remains a concern. Voters punishing incumbents for failure and rewarding alternatives, however imperfect, is precisely how accountability is supposed to work. The ANC's historic dominance, after all, was never a guarantee of good governance, and its erosion may force a political culture less reliant on liberation credentials and more attentive to competence, a shift one analyst in the reporting described as voters choosing based on capability rather than history or skin colour.

Still, the practical stakes for ordinary residents are immediate and unforgiving. Coalition paralysis does not pause while politicians negotiate; water infrastructure continues to fail, crime persists, and economic stagnation compounds. For readers elsewhere in Southern Africa, where single-party dominance remains more entrenched, South Africa's experience offers an instructive, if cautionary, preview: fragmented mandates can either produce more responsive, pluralistic governance or descend into the kind of administrative drift that erodes public trust even further. The region should watch closely whether South Africa's coalition negotiators prioritise durable governance frameworks over narrow power-sharing formulas, because the answer will signal whether multiparty democracy at the local level can actually deliver, or whether it simply distributes dysfunction more broadly. The coming weeks of negotiation, not the election night itself, will determine which path South Africa takes.

Reporting context: - Mashaba Says Chance of Coalitions With the DA Is "Very, Very Slim": /article/mashaba-says-chance-of-coalitions-with-the-da-is-very-very-slim-f4005d7570 - Ramaphosa Says Voters' Verdict Must Be Respected as ANC Secretary-General Calls Local Election Result "Catastrophic": /article/ramaphosa-says-voters-verdict-must-be-respected-as-anc-secretary-gen-4d1a123096 - ANC Finishes With 30.76% in Final Municipal Results, Its Lowest Ever Share: /article/anc-finishes-with-30-76-in-final-municipal-results-its-lowest-ever-s-0552d82c68 - ANC Heads for Record-Low Local Vote and Loses Majority in Six of Eight Metros: /article/anc-heads-for-record-low-local-vote-and-loses-majority-in-six-of-eig-692cb99609 - ANC Posts Worst Result in Its History in South Africa Local Elections as Coalition Talks Loom: /article/anc-posts-worst-result-in-its-history-in-south-africa-local-election-5cb796f015 - ANC Set to Miss Outright Majority in All Eight Major Metros as Coalition Talks Loom in South Africa: /article/anc-set-to-miss-outright-majority-in-all-eight-major-metros-as-coali-2f8fa7cbd7

More reporting from Voice of Africans