Opinion & Thought Leadership · Southern Africa
South Africa's Coalition Reckoning: The ANC's Local Defeat Is a Test for the Whole Region
By: Tumi Dlamini
The ANC's worst-ever local election result, falling to roughly 31% and losing control of 110 municipalities, marks a historic rupture in South African politics. This column argues that the shift towards coalition governance, while destabilising in the short term, could ultimately deepen accountability across Southern Africa if handled with restraint.
South Africa's local elections have delivered a verdict that few could have imagined a decade ago. The African National Congress, the party that has governed continuously since 1994, has recorded its worst-ever local result, taking about 31 percent of the vote against roughly 25 percent for the Democratic Alliance. It has lost control of 110 municipalities and, perhaps most symbolically, no longer leads the councils of Johannesburg, Pretoria and Ekurhuleni. The party remains nationally the largest, but its dominance over South Africa's urban heartlands has ended. This is not merely an electoral setback; it is a structural turning point, and its implications will be felt well beyond South Africa's borders.
The reported facts are instructive in their specificity. The ANC's 31 percent compares with 46 percent in 2021 and 66 percent in 2006, a decline so steep and sustained that it cannot be dismissed as a single bad cycle. Secretary-General Fikile Mbalula called the result "catastrophic," a rare admission from a party long practised in managing its own narrative. President Cyril Ramaphosa, for his part, has urged parties entering coalition negotiations to act with humility and to prioritise service delivery over the pursuit of power. Analysts cited in the reporting, including Sipho Seepe and Ralph Mathekga, describe coalitions as South Africa's "new normal" and the vote as a referendum on the ANC's governing capacity. These are reported assessments, not settled facts, but they align with the numbers themselves.
What should readers across Southern Africa make of this moment? My own view is that the ANC's decline, however uncomfortable for a party with the moral authority of the liberation struggle behind it, is a healthy correction for South African democracy, provided the coalition era that follows is managed with genuine seriousness rather than opportunism. The complaints driving voters away, water and electricity failures, deteriorating roads, uncollected refuse, are not abstractions. They are the daily texture of municipal governance, and their persistence under one-party dominance for three decades suggests that competition, however messy, was overdue. A governing party insulated from the risk of losing power has less incentive to fix the basics. The challenge now is whether multiparty bargaining produces better basics, or simply trades one set of failures for a different, more fragmented set of them.
Here the fair counterargument deserves weight. Coalition government in cities as large and complex as Johannesburg has, in recent years, proven volatile rather than stabilising, with frequent changes of mayor and administrative drift. The reported concern from analyst Sandile Mnguni, that the shift could produce stalemates and unstable alliances, is not speculative pessimism but a recognition of recent municipal history. With parties given only 14 days to reach agreements before councils are formed, the risk of rushed, transactional deals rather than policy-driven partnerships is real. The DA's stated preference for partners committed to clean government and the rule of law, rather than an arrangement with the ANC, signals that ideological sorting may replace the ANC's old catch-all coalition logic, a potentially healthier but also potentially more exclusionary dynamic for smaller parties and the voters who back them.
For African readers beyond South Africa's borders, the practical implications are significant. South Africa remains the continent's most industrialised economy and a bellwether for investor sentiment in the region, as reflected in reporting on the rand firming even as coalition talks dominate market attention. Protracted municipal instability, especially in Johannesburg, Pretoria and Ekurhuleni, carries direct economic consequences: disrupted services affect businesses, undermine investor confidence, and ripple into regional supply chains and labour markets that depend on South African demand. Equally, the political lesson is transferable. Across Southern Africa, from Angola's MPLA moving to confirm a third presidential term for João Lourenço to Zimbabwe's continued one-party dominance, the ANC's example offers a cautionary tale about what happens when ruling parties govern without serious electoral jeopardy for decades. Whether that lesson is absorbed by other ruling parties in the region, or dismissed as a uniquely South African phenomenon, will shape how competitive the next decade of Southern African politics becomes.
What happens in the coming weeks, as parties negotiate within that 14-day window, will test whether South Africa's institutions can convert a punishing electoral verdict into more responsive governance, or whether fragmentation simply replaces the old frustrations with new ones. Ramaphosa's own position adds a further layer of uncertainty, with reporting suggesting he may step aside as party leader ahead of the 2027 leadership contest. For a region watching closely, the stakes extend well past Pretoria's city hall.
Reporting context: - ANC's Worst Local Election Result Points to Coalition Era in South Africa, Analysts Say: /article/anc-s-worst-local-election-result-points-to-coalition-era-in-south-a-7767c20098 - Ramaphosa Urges Parties to Put Service Delivery Ahead of Power in Coalition Talks: /article/ramaphosa-urges-parties-to-put-service-delivery-ahead-of-power-in-co-2f6f3cf802 - Angola's MPLA Backs President Lourenço's Candidacy for a Third Term: /article/angola-s-mpla-backs-president-louren-o-s-candidacy-for-a-third-term-e5b120fefd - South African Rand Firms as Oil Prices Soften and Coalition Talks Stay in Focus: /article/south-african-rand-firms-as-oil-prices-soften-and-coalition-talks-st-20b65aceda - ANC Loses Control of 110 Municipalities in Election Setback: /article/anc-loses-control-of-110-municipalities-in-election-setback-f835015b1f