Opinion & Thought Leadership · North Africa
Sudan's Day of Reckoning: Why Verdicts and Arrest Warrants Must Not Become Substitutes for Peace
By: Nicol Adam
Death sentences against Hemedti and the arrest of Bashir-era official Ahmed Haroun mark a legal reckoning for Sudan's war, but courtroom drama risks eclipsing the harder task of ending a conflict that has killed over 200,000 people. North Africa's institutions must insist that justice complement, not replace, a political settlement.
Two Sudanese legal developments, reported within days of one another, deserve to be read together rather than in isolation. A Sudanese criminal court has sentenced Rapid Support Forces leader Mohamed Hamdan Dagalo, known as Hemedti, and thirteen others to death. Separately, the Sudanese army has announced the arrest of Ahmed Haroun, a former interior minister under Omar al-Bashir who has been sought by the International Criminal Court for two decades over alleged war crimes in Darfur. Civil society groups and human rights organisations, including Human Rights Watch, are now pressing Khartoum's military authorities to transfer Haroun to The Hague, accusing General Abdel Fattah al-Burhan of obstructing international justice.
Taken together, these two threads suggest a country whose institutions are, in some fashion, attempting to settle accounts with both its recent and more distant past. That impulse is understandable and, in principle, welcome. Sudan's war, which humanitarian workers estimate has killed more than 200,000 people and which the United Nations has called the world's worst humanitarian crisis, cries out for accountability. Yet the available reporting leaves crucial facts unconfirmed: the charges underlying Hemedti's death sentence, the court that issued it, whether the defendants were present, and whether appeals remain open. Haroun's whereabouts in detention have not been disclosed by Sudanese authorities. These gaps matter, because verdicts delivered without transparency invite as much scepticism as they do satisfaction.
The central interpretive question is whether these legal actions represent a genuine turn toward accountability or a selective use of justice by one side of a still-active civil war. Hemedti and al-Burhan were partners in the 2021 ousting of Sudan's fragile civilian transition before their rivalry over integrating the RSF into the regular army exploded into open war in 2023. A court operating under the authority of al-Burhan's army sentencing his battlefield adversary to death is not, by itself, proof of impartial justice; it is equally consistent with a victor's tribunal dispensed amid an unresolved conflict. The same logic applies, in reverse, to the pressure now building around Haroun: his arrest followed his own decision to resurface publicly, and the demand that he be sent to the ICC is a test of whether Sudan's army, having captured a long-sought fugitive, will honour obligations under UN Security Council Resolution 1593 or treat him as a bargaining chip.
For readers across North Africa and the wider continent, the stakes extend well beyond Sudan's borders. The region has, in the same news cycle, watched Libya detain 483 undocumented Eritrean migrants and the ICC set a trial date over crimes linked to Mitiga, a reminder that displacement, impunity and fragile justice systems are not confined to one country. Sudan's crisis has already pushed refugees into Chad, Egypt and beyond, straining neighbours whose own institutions are far from robust. A Sudan where justice is seen to be an instrument of whichever faction currently holds Khartoum will not produce the stability that returning refugees, regional trade and cross-border investment depend upon. Conversely, a credible accounting — one that reaches perpetrators regardless of which side of the front line they stood on — could begin to rebuild the kind of institutional trust that any post-war settlement will require.
There is a reasonable counterargument to treating these developments with suspicion. Supporters of swift domestic prosecution might argue that waiting for a tidy, internationally sanctioned process risks indefinite delay while atrocities continue, and that Sudanese courts, however imperfect, at least demonstrate that impunity has consequences. Human rights advocates pressing for Haroun's ICC transfer are not naive about al-Burhan's motives; they are using the moment of his capture to extract a concrete legal obligation that Sudan has evaded for two decades. That pressure is itself a legitimate and probably necessary check on a government that might otherwise quietly let the matter lapse once international attention moves elsewhere.
My own view is that neither the death sentence nor the arrest should be mistaken for the resolution the region needs. Capital punishment handed down in the middle of an active war, by a court whose independence cannot be verified from the available record, settles nothing if the war itself continues to generate fresh atrocities. The more consequential test is whether Sudan's army actually transfers Haroun to The Hague, as international law requires, rather than using his detention as leverage in negotiations with al-Burhan's domestic and foreign patrons. African governments, the African Union and regional blocs with influence over Khartoum should press for transparency on both fronts: public disclosure of the legal basis for the death sentences and a firm, verifiable timetable for Haroun's transfer. Anything less allows courts and arrest warrants to function as theatre for a war that justice alone cannot end.
For African readers, the practical implication is sobering. Legal accountability, however welcome, is not a substitute for a negotiated end to the fighting between the army and the RSF. Until that negotiation happens, verdicts delivered from Khartoum's courtrooms will remain, at best, partial and provisional measures of justice — and at worst, instruments of a war still being fought by other means.
Reporting context: - Pressure Grows on Sudan to Hand Former Bashir Aide Ahmed Haroun to the ICC: /article/pressure-grows-on-sudan-to-hand-former-bashir-aide-ahmed-haroun-to-t-bbf12fd545 - Sudanese Court Sentences RSF Leader Hemedti and 13 Others to Death: /article/sudanese-court-sentences-rsf-leader-hemedti-and-13-others-to-death-7dd49cdcda - Libya Detains 483 Undocumented Eritrean Migrants: /article/libya-detains-483-undocumented-eritrean-migrants-d2068ddce0 - ICC Sets Trial Date Over Crimes Linked to Mitiga in Libya: /article/icc-sets-trial-date-over-crimes-linked-to-mitiga-in-libya-681a45192f