Opinion & Thought Leadership · Southern Africa
The ANC's Reckoning: Why "Soul-Searching" Must Mean More Than a Slogan
By: Tumi Dlamini
After the ANC's worst-ever local election result, the party promises reflection while insisting President Ramaphosa stays. This column argues the moment demands structural change, not reassurance, as coalition arithmetic, opposition bloc-building and service-delivery failures converge to test South Africa's governing settlement.
South Africa's governing party has suffered its worst local election result since the end of apartheid, and its response so far has been a familiar one: a promise of "soul-searching" paired with an immediate insistence that nothing fundamental will change at the top. National spokesperson Mahlengi Bhengu-Motsiri has confirmed that President Cyril Ramaphosa will not resign, dismissing suggestions to the contrary as fabrication, even as the party's National Executive Committee convened in special session to confront a vote share that fell fifteen percentage points to roughly thirty-one percent. The secretary-general's own word for the outcome, "catastrophic," is not one party officials use lightly, and it signals that the gap between rhetoric and reality is narrowing in ways the ANC can no longer paper over.
The scale of the decline deserves to be stated plainly, because it is easy to become numb to a slow erosion that has now become a rout. A party that once commanded roughly seventy percent of the national vote has watched support drift away continuously since losing its parliamentary majority two years ago, when it fell to forty percent nationally. The slide from forty to thirty-one percent in local elections is not a plateau; it is an acceleration. Reported context suggests the public's frustrations are concrete rather than ideological: electricity shortages, failing water and sewage infrastructure, uncollected refuse, and a housing shortfall that leaves millions in informal shacks. The ANC's historical appeals to the legacy of apartheid and colonialism, while not without foundation as explanations for deep structural inequality, increasingly sit uneasily alongside voters' more immediate demand for competent municipal governance. This is an interpretation worth stating carefully: the reporting does not quantify how many voters cite service delivery over historical grievance, but the juxtaposition offered in the coverage is itself telling of where the political centre of gravity has moved.
What makes this moment distinct from previous ANC setbacks is the speed with which opposition and smaller parties are moving to capitalise on the fragmentation. Separate reporting indicates that the uMkhonto weSizwe party, the Economic Freedom Fighters and the South African Communist Party have formed a bloc intended to drive agendas within municipal councils, offering the ANC conditional support rather than unconditional partnership. The precise terms of that conditionality are not detailed in the available reporting, nor are the specific municipalities affected, but the strategic logic is clear enough: with no single party holding outright majorities in a number of councils, the ANC must now negotiate from a position of weakness with ideologically disparate actors who each have their own incentives to extract concessions. Coalition talks described elsewhere as "high-stakes" are underway, though the parties involved, the venues and the substantive terms remain undisclosed in current reporting. This is precisely the kind of negotiation where the details matter enormously and where premature judgment would be unwise; readers should treat any confident forecast of outcomes with scepticism until agreements are actually tabled.
There is a reasonable counterargument to the view that the ANC's troubles are primarily self-inflicted. The party's leadership has pointed, as it has before, to the enduring weight of apartheid-era spatial and economic inequality as a structural constraint on what any governing party could plausibly deliver in three decades. There is also a fair point to be made that South Africa's coalition arithmetic is a feature of a maturing, pluralistic democracy rather than a crisis in itself; fragmented councils requiring negotiation are not inherently dysfunctional, and the emergence of smaller parties able to bargain for municipal agendas could, in principle, produce more responsive local governance than one-party dominance ever did. Separately, Ramaphosa's continued international engagement, including a reported visit to the United States centred on artificial intelligence amid the backdrop of US visa sanctions, suggests a presidency still attempting to project stability and forward motion even as the domestic political ground shifts beneath it. Whether that posture reassures markets or voters is not something the available reporting allows this column to settle.
Still, the practical stakes for African readers, and for South Africans in particular, are immediate rather than theoretical. Rising power costs are already reported to be threatening manufacturing jobs and investment in Nelson Mandela Bay, a concrete illustration of the service-delivery failures voters are punishing at the ballot box. If coalition negotiations produce paralysis rather than functional governance in the councils most affected by these pressures, the costs will not be borne by party headquarters but by residents waiting for electricity, water and refuse collection to simply work. The ANC's promised "soul-searching" will be tested not in NEC communiqués but in whether the coalition deals now being negotiated produce councils capable of reversing that decline. A party insisting its president will not resign is not the same as a party demonstrating it has absorbed the lesson voters have delivered; only the substance of the agreements now being negotiated, and the competence of the governance that follows, will show which is true.
Reporting context: - South African Parties Enter High-Stakes Coalition Talks After ANC's Worst Election Result: /article/south-african-parties-enter-high-stakes-coalition-talks-after-anc-s--0aa4f0b12a - MK, EFF and SACP Form Bloc to Push Municipal Agendas, Offering ANC Conditional Support: /article/mk-eff-and-sacp-form-bloc-to-push-municipal-agendas-offering-anc-con-66b51fc2bf - Rising Power Costs Threaten Manufacturing Jobs and Investment in Nelson Mandela Bay</panel>: /article/rising-power-costs-threaten-manufacturing-jobs-and-investment-in-nel-eb545956c6 - Ramaphosa Makes AI-Focused US Visit as Trump's Visa Sanctions Loom Over Ties: /article/ramaphosa-makes-ai-focused-us-visit-as-trump-s-visa-sanctions-loom-o-f574eefde9 - ANC Pledges "Soul-Searching" After Election Losses and Says Ramaphosa Will Not Resign: /article/anc-pledges-soul-searching-after-election-losses-and-says-ramaphosa--6310bf9b7f