Opinion & Thought Leadership · North Africa

Tunisia's Courts Are Becoming the Measure of Its Politics

By: Nicol Adam

Within days, a Tunisian military court jailed opposition figure Olfa Hamdi and a civilian court sentenced ten Gabes anti-pollution activists. Read together, the rulings suggest a judiciary increasingly deployed against dissent, with implications for Tunisia's democratic credibility and for how African publics judge governance beyond elections.

Two courtrooms, two very different disputes, one unmistakable pattern. This week a Tunisian military tribunal sentenced Olfa Hamdi, leader of the opposition Third Republic Party and a dual Tunisian-American national, to four years in prison over social media posts, on charges of plotting against state security and inciting the military to disobey orders. Days earlier, a civilian court in Gabes sentenced ten environmental activists, eight to suspended terms and two to a year in jail, for a 2020 protest against pollution from a state-owned phosphate plant. Taken separately, each case has its own facts and legal texture. Taken together, reported alongside the largest street protests against President Kais Saied in years, they describe a judiciary whose rulings are increasingly difficult to separate from the political climate in which they are delivered.

The thesis here is modest but important: it is not that Tunisian courts are simply instruments of the presidency, a claim the available reporting does not establish and which Saied himself disputes, insisting the law applies to everyone regardless of position. It is that the pattern of outcomes, dissidents and environmental campaigners facing prison terms while the government pursues an economically vital phosphate expansion, is becoming the metric by which Tunisia's democratic trajectory is now read, inside the country and beyond it. That is a reputational fact independent of whether any individual verdict was legally sound.

Consider the specifics as reported. Hamdi's four-year sentence stacks two two-year terms atop fines of roughly $26,000, following an earlier two-year sentence in March on separate charges. She had sought to contest the 2024 presidential election before being disqualified on an age technicality, and was detained at the airport upon returning to Tunisia in February. Human rights organisations have criticised the proceedings, and the US State Department says it is "closely tracking the situation." These are facts drawn from her lawyer and from international reaction, not independent verification of the underlying conduct; the reporting does not detail the content of the social-media posts or the evidentiary basis for the security charges, and that gap matters for anyone trying to judge the case on its merits rather than its optics.

The Gabes case raises a different but adjacent concern. The activists were prosecuted by the state-owned factory itself, which accused them of obstructing operations, after protests over pollution that researchers have linked to radioactive industrial waste. Campaigners say they believed the matter had been dropped, only to discover an in-absentia conviction from 2023 that produced this retrial. A court had already rejected calls in February to suspend the plant's operations. The timing is notable: these sentences land just as Tunisia pursues a stated plan to more than quadruple phosphate production by 2030, a sector President Saied regards as central to reviving the economy. Nothing in the available reporting proves that economic priority shaped the verdict. But the coincidence of environmental dissent being punished precisely as the industry it targets prepares to scale up is the kind of correlation that invites scrutiny, fair or not.

A reasonable counterargument deserves airing. Governments facing genuine security threats, economic strain and industrial-sabotage allegations retain a legitimate interest in prosecuting incitement or obstruction, and military courts handling cases involving the armed forces are not unique to Tunisia. Saied's own defence, that the law is applied without regard to political standing, cannot be dismissed outright on the evidence supplied here; the reporting does not include the charge sheets, trial transcripts or government rebuttals that would allow a confident verdict on guilt or innocence in either case. Readers should resist the temptation to convert incomplete information into a sweeping conclusion that Tunisian justice has been wholly captured.

Yet the practical implications for African readers, and for Tunisia's regional standing, do not depend on resolving that legal question. Across the continent, courts are frequently the last visible check on executive power when elections are contested or compressed. When military tribunals try civilians for speech, and when state-owned enterprises wield prosecutorial leverage against environmental protest, investors, multilateral partners and ordinary citizens alike tend to discount formal guarantees of rule of law. That discounting carries costs: it complicates foreign investment of the kind Tunisia needs for its vocational-training and industrial ambitions, and it narrows the space in which citizens can contest policy, including the environmental costs of the very phosphate expansion the state is banking on.

The responsible position, pending fuller disclosure of evidence in both cases, is to treat the Hamdi and Gabes verdicts not as proof of a verdict already reached about Tunisian democracy, but as data points that the government itself must now actively counter with transparency, open appeals and public accounting for why security and industrial-obstruction charges were deemed to fit speech and protest. Absent that, the cases will continue to be read, fairly or not, as confirmation of a narrowing political space, and Tunisia's courts, rather than its ballots, will remain the primary measure by which its democratic health is judged.

Reporting context: - Tunisian Military Court Jails Opposition Leader Olfa Hamdi for Four Years: /article/tunisian-military-court-jails-opposition-leader-olfa-hamdi-for-four--de1b712288 - Tunisian Court Sentences Ten Environmental Activists Over 2020 Gabes Pollution Protest: /article/tunisian-court-sentences-ten-environmental-activists-over-2020-gabes-ca23015554

More reporting from Voice of Africans