Opinion & Thought Leadership · East Africa

Two Courts, One Question: Can East Africa's Judiciaries Hold the Line?

By: Amara Tesfaye

As Tanzania's Lissu appeals a four-year incitement sentence after acquittal on treason, and Somalia's president faces accusations of confronting the Supreme Court over his term extension, East Africa confronts a shared test: whether judicial rulings constrain power or merely dress political compromise in legal language.

East Africa is witnessing two simultaneous tests of constitutional restraint, and they deserve to be read together rather than in isolation. In Tanzania, a court cleared opposition leader Tundu Lissu of treason but sentenced him to four years for "incitement," a charge his lawyers say was never formally put to him before trial. In Somalia, the Supreme Court ruled that President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud's term extension was unlawful, and the president's office responded, according to opposition accounts that could not be independently verified, by moving to dismiss the chief justice and deploying troops near the court. Different countries, different legal traditions, but the same underlying question: what happens when a government loses patience with the institutions meant to check it.

The Tanzanian case is instructive precisely because of what the state did not do. Prosecutors dropped a treason charge that could have carried the death penalty, and Chadema, Lissu's party, understandably called the outcome a "victorious day." But converting a capital charge into a four-year sentence for incitement is not the same as vindicating due process. Lissu's lead counsel, Rugemeleza Nshala, has raised a procedural objection that courts anywhere should take seriously: a defendant cannot adequately answer a charge he was not told he faced. Whether or not the appeal succeeds, the sequence of events, as reported, suggests a judiciary calibrating outcomes to political as much as legal considerations. The analyst quoted in the reporting called the verdict a compromise that lets President Samia Suluhu Hassan keep Lissu confined while blunting international criticism after last year's deadly crackdown. That reading may be too neat, but it captures something real: sentences can function as signals to foreign observers as much as judgments on facts.

Somalia's crisis is more acute because it involves open confrontation between the executive and the judiciary rather than a single contested verdict. A Supreme Court ruling that a leader's term extension is unlawful is about as direct a constitutional rebuke as exists. The reported response, including an attempt to dismiss the chief justice and the alleged movement of troops to the court premises, would, if accurate, represent an executive refusing to accept the authority of the body meant to constrain it. The caveat matters: these specific allegations of troop deployment and arrest attempts come from opposition figures and have not been independently confirmed, even though images said to show military forces at the court have circulated. Mogadishu residents are reported to be divided, which is itself a sign that the ruling has not settled the argument it was meant to resolve. The court's own prescription, a new political agreement within 30 days and elections within 90, is a narrow window in a country already absorbing the announced withdrawal of its largest troop contributor to the African Union mission against al-Shabaab by the end of 2027.

The counterargument deserves airing. Governments facing genuine security threats, mass unrest, or contested transitions sometimes argue that rigid adherence to procedure can itself become a vehicle for paralysis or for actors unwilling to accept electoral outcomes. Tanzania's government would likely say the incitement charge reflects a real call to disrupt elections, not mere political speech. Somalia's presidency frames its term extension as a necessary bridge to the country's first full democratic elections, a genuinely difficult undertaking in a system still partly organized around clan-based representation. These are not frivolous positions, and readers should resist the temptation to assume bad faith is the only explanation on offer. The available reporting, in both cases, is partial: we do not have full trial transcripts, the text of Burundi-style decrees, or verified footage from Mogadishu, and conclusions should be held with appropriate humility.

Still, the pattern across these two cases is harder to dismiss than either case alone. When courts are used to produce politically convenient middle outcomes, or when courts are confronted with executive force rather than appeal, the damage is not confined to the individuals immediately affected. It is measured in whether citizens, investors, and regional partners can trust that rulings mean what they say. For East African readers, the practical stakes are concrete: donor governments already watching Tanzania's post-election crackdown and Somalia's funding shortfall for the anti-al-Shabaab mission will calibrate aid, investment and security cooperation partly on these signals. A region courting Chinese trade expansion, as Ethiopia is doing at the import expo, or foreign capital for electricity access, as Uganda is pursuing, cannot fully insulate those ambitions from perceptions of institutional fragility elsewhere in the neighbourhood.

The reasonable position is not that every executive-judiciary clash is illegitimate, but that the burden of proof should sit with governments claiming necessity, not with citizens demanding transparency. Tanzania's appellate court now has an opportunity to clarify, on the narrow procedural question Lissu's lawyers have raised, whether notice of charges is a formality or a right. Somalia's political actors have 30 days, per the court's own ruling, to show whether an agreement can be reached without further confrontation. Neither outcome is guaranteed, and neither should be assumed. What can be said with confidence is that the coming weeks in both countries will reveal more about the durability of East African constitutionalism than any single verdict already delivered.

Reporting context: - Tundu Lissu's Lawyers Launch Appeal Against Four-Year Incitement Sentence: /article/tundu-lissu-s-lawyers-launch-appeal-against-four-year-incitement-sen-1827976cb1 - Tanzania's Chadema Hails 'Victorious Day' After Tundu Lissu Cleared of Treason but Jailed for Incitement: /article/tanzania-s-chadema-hails-victorious-day-after-tundu-lissu-cleared-of-f2ef72f340 - Somalia's Opposition Accuses President of Sending Troops to Supreme Court After Term Extension Ruled Unlawful: /article/somalia-s-opposition-accuses-president-of-sending-troops-to-supreme--eae36b0918

More reporting from Voice of Africans