Opinion & Thought Leadership · East Africa
Uganda's Disappeared: A Test of Whether the Rule of Law Still Exists
By: Amara Tesfaye
The reappearance of Sam Mugumya after fifteen months of enforced disappearance, visibly weakened and now charged before a military tribunal, exposes a pattern of impunity in Uganda that should alarm the region. His case, set against Rwanda's own entanglements and Ethiopia's spiralling displacement crisis, demands that East Africans insist on accountability over silence.
Of all the developments competing for attention across East Africa this week, none carries the weight of Sam Mugumya's reappearance before a Ugandan military tribunal. A former aide to opposition leader Kizza Besigye, Mugumya vanished in August 2025 after what his lawyer describes as an abduction by Ugandan soldiers. For nearly fifteen months, the state insisted, repeatedly and under oath in court proceedings, that it was not holding him. He has now resurfaced, visibly emaciated, struggling to walk, and facing a charge of treason he disputes. This is not a minor procedural footnote. It is a story that speaks to the architecture of power in Uganda and to the credibility of institutions meant to restrain it.
The facts, as reported, are stark enough on their own without embellishment. A citizen disappears. The military denies custody. Courts are told, apparently falsely, that he cannot be produced. Video footage circulating publicly in October showed a man with stiffened limbs relearning to walk, a detail consistent with prolonged restraint rather than ordinary detention. Agather Atuhaire of the Agora Centre for Research has called this a climate of impunity, noting that Ugandan courts are unlikely to probe the state's own sworn misrepresentations or its disregard for orders to produce him. That is a serious allegation, and it should be treated as her assessment rather than established fact. But the pattern it describes, a government that disappears critics, denies it, then eventually charges them before a military rather than civilian court, is one East African readers have seen before, most notably in the case of Besigye himself, abducted in Kenya and held in Uganda since, now reportedly in intensive care.
The interpretation I want to advance is this: Uganda's handling of Mugumya is not an isolated aberration but a symptom of a deeper erosion, one in which military tribunals have become a preferred venue for silencing political opposition precisely because they sit outside the ordinary safeguards of civilian justice. When a state can detain a person incommunicado for over a year, deny it to judges, and then produce him only to charge him with treason, the message to every dissenting voice in the country is unambiguous. This matters well beyond Uganda's borders. A region that aspires to integrated markets, free movement of people and shared infrastructure, from the crude oil pipeline Kampala and Dar es Salaam are now racing to fast-track, to the East African Legislative Assembly's quieter work on seed sovereignty, cannot credibly present itself to investors and citizens alike as stable if its core institutions tolerate enforced disappearance as an instrument of statecraft.
A fair accounting requires acknowledging counterarguments. Governments facing genuine security threats, including armed opposition movements, sometimes argue that extraordinary measures and military justice are necessary responses to extraordinary circumstances, and Uganda's officials would likely frame the treason charge in precisely those terms. There is also an evidentiary gap in what has been publicly reported: we know Mugumya's physical condition drew public alarm and that his lawyer alleges abduction by soldiers, but we do not have the government's full account of the intervening fifteen months, nor independent medical assessment of what caused his condition. Readers should hold the state's denials and the family's and advocates' accusations in tension until a fuller record emerges, ideally through the very court proceedings now underway, however imperfect that forum may be.
Still, the asymmetry of information itself is instructive. It is the state, not Mugumya's family, that controlled his whereabouts and his access to the outside world for over a year. That imbalance of power is precisely why human rights organisations and the United Nations have flagged forced disappearances as an intensifying concern in Uganda, and why the case deserves sustained attention rather than being absorbed into the news cycle alongside lower-stakes stories of pipelines, coffee value chains or football scores.
What should follow from this, in practical terms, is modest but important. Ugandan courts, even military ones, should be pressed by lawyers, civil society and regional bodies to establish a credible, documented account of where Mugumya was held and why the state's earlier denials diverged so sharply from the facts now evident in his physical condition. East African neighbours and regional institutions, including the East African Legislative Assembly, have an interest in insisting that disputes over disappeared citizens not be treated as a purely domestic matter, given the precedent such cases set for an integrating region. And ordinary citizens across East Africa, who have followed Besigye's own prolonged detention with evident unease, should recognise in Mugumya's case not a distant political quarrel but a warning about how readily state power can operate beyond the reach of law when scrutiny lapses. The test now is whether Uganda's judicial process, however constrained its venue, can produce answers rather than further silence.
Reporting context: - Rwanda's Foreign Minister Says US Takes "Unbalanced Approach" to DR Congo Peace Deal: /article/rwanda-s-foreign-minister-says-us-takes-unbalanced-approach-to-dr-co-1be6d8a489 - Uganda and Tanzania Move to Fast-Track Crude Oil Pipeline: /article/uganda-and-tanzania-move-to-fast-track-crude-oil-pipeline-5443e93b50 - Ugandan Opposition Aide Sam Mugumya Appears in Military Court After 15 Months Missing, Charged With Treason: /article/ugandan-opposition-aide-sam-mugumya-appears-in-military-court-after--a581f91fd8 - EALA Pushes Bill to Safeguard Indigenous Seeds: /article/eala-pushes-bill-to-safeguard-indigenous-seeds-dbca0054cd