International ยท International
US Health Secretary's Remarks on Arab Science Draw Backlash and Historical Rebuttals
US Health Secretary Robert F Kennedy Jr has drawn criticism after saying Arabs do not produce science or literature. Critics called the remarks racist and inaccurate, citing Arab scholarship from the Islamic Golden Age and modern Nobel, Fields and Wolf prize winners, including Egyptians.
US Health Secretary Robert F Kennedy Jr has faced widespread criticism over remarks in which he said Arabs "don't produce science", do not win major prizes and do not produce literature.
He made the comments on Monday at a campaign event in Grand Rapids, Michigan, where he was backing Republican Senate nominee Mike Rogers. Rogers is competing against Arab-American Democrat Abdul El-Sayed in a tightly contested race for the state's Senate seat in next week's midterm elections. Kennedy has previously been involved in anti-vaccine campaigns and has promoted a debunked theory linking vaccines to autism.
Critics described the statements as racist, Islamophobic and factually wrong. They pointed to the Islamic Golden Age, roughly 750 to 1258, when Arabic was the main language of science and scholarship. Examples cited include al-Khwarizmi, often called the father of algebra; Ibn al-Haytham, known for work on optics; surgeon Abu al-Qasim al-Zahrawi; and Ibn al-Nafis, who described pulmonary circulation while working in Egypt. Fatima al-Fihri's founding of the University of al-Qarawiyyin in Fez, Morocco, is also often cited as the origin of the oldest continually operating university.
Modern examples were also raised. Egyptian writer Naguib Mahfouz won the Nobel Prize in Literature and remains the only laureate to have written in Arabic. Egyptian chemist Ahmed Zewail won both the Nobel and Wolf prizes in chemistry, and Mohamed ElBaradei shared a Nobel prize with the International Atomic Energy Agency. Others named include Omar Yaghi, a Jordan-born chemist of Palestinian refugee background who won the Wolf Prize in 2018 and a Nobel Prize in Chemistry, and Moungi Bawendi, born in France to a Tunisian father.
Broadcaster Mehdi Hasan called the remarks racist. Vaccine scientist Peter Hotez said Arab scholars of the Middle Ages preserved the works of Aristotle, Hippocrates and Galen. The Council on American-Islamic Relations called for Kennedy's removal, accusing him of promoting fabricated claims and fuelling anti-Arab and anti-Muslim hate. Kennedy had not responded in the material available.